I believe that if there WAS a third party, it was just a lone neutral player.
However, now that you bring this up noble: [quote=“NobleBrutus, post:267, topic:5314”]
My belief is that ‘the defector’ was a sleeper role
[/quote]
Perhaps it is time I let everyone know what I learned during the night.
So, yesterday some of you might have noticed that @Hollifer posted this, in violation of the edit rule it is now deleted I believe:
Last night I questioned her about her role, and she claimed to be immune to dying at night, without exception, and could “visit” other players to protect them. However, due to my paranoia with another player, I asked for her role name. She claims to be the “Seductress”. If any of you google “Mafia game Seductress” this is the first link youll find:
http://www.mafiauniverse.com/forums/database/mafia-roles/role/?mafiarole=Converter
On this wikipedia page it describes a role called the “Converter”, sometimes called a “Seductress”. This role is a wolf/Mafia role, and is used to convert other players to the wolf team.
Role Description:
The Converter is a mafia-aligned player with a 1-shot night ability to convert someone to the mafia team.
On night 1 Hollifer was locked up, and thus could not convert anyone. Last night, after learning this, I asked the Jailer to lock her up again to ensure she could not convert anyone else - namely, me as I was afraid with my status in the game people might trust me with confidential information, and potentially convert me. Yes, I am aware of the existence of a Jailer role. I wont say who it is.
Now, I’m not saying for SURE that Martin made the Seductress role the same as the wiki. In fact, it doesn’t seem like something he would do. However, I can’t ignore the possibility that such a dangerous role could potentially be in the hands of a wolf.
I’m a bit embarrassed to say that despite freaking out and stressing hardcore last night, I did not even consider Noble’s idea. I’m glad he got it into the open. It is possible that Hollifer’s role could ONLY be used on the Defector. I have no idea.
Either way, its fishy as hell.
What do you all think? @NobleBrutus @Lomsor And I’d especially I’d like to hear from @TerranAmbass about yesterday and today. I see he says he doesn’t really have much else to contribute, but thats a total lie. Come on man. What did you think of Cosmos’ argument? What did you make of BrickWall’s arguments about the roles? Why do you think the poll was manipulated? What do you think of Hollifer now that I’ve revealed this information? We need as much info as you can provide us, so we can determine whether you are a wolf or a human. If you don’t provide this information, I guess well have to assume youre intentionally not posting much in order to deprive us of that information…
I don’t know if anyone should trust me 100%. I was hoping Cosmos would have been a wolf, and we could start forming an alliance last night, but that didn’t pan out. You’ll have to make up your own minds about me based on the way I’ve been posting so far throughout the game.
