Man. That was a lot of reading. I’m going to post my notes in this paste-bin for anyone else to read, I dont want to take up space in thread with it. Its quite long, but much briefer than the thread i assure you, and i hope you find it useful:
Link to Notes
First of all, I want to say this: I think Skyentist, Sane, Matt, Noble, Terran, Topper, Lucas, Cosmos, Cybercritic and Enginish are all humans. Unfortunately, because of the information overload, I have now voted for and lynched two of those people, along with you all… Also, if you guys arent human, then you are playing extremely well, and screw you, you bastards. My reasoning for this is based on their posts and strictly my opinion of how “human-ey” their posts seemed to me.
Also, two of those are now murdered, but only enginish would have been on that list without having been killed. Cyber was too quiet for my tastes, and never really contributed. Makes me wonder why he was killed.
On to my suspects, which obviously is everyone I didnt name:
Cise
Arkenbrien
Pendrokar
Krishna
Xamino
As Enginish did, I am again working under the assumption that there are four wolves this game, as last game, and this fits nicely with my suspects, as I dont think we have killed any wolves yet, and I’m fairly certain that either Pendrokar or Xamino is a human, but I cant decide which it is.
Krishna has simply not contributed anything at all to the game, I mean literally nothing. Not even one post has been constructive to our discussions, and he seems to only respond when pressured, yet is following the game actively. Krishna also voted for both Topper and Cosmos, as a note.
Arkenbrien is hard to nail down in any wolf game because of his behavior, but I have to say he has not really contributed much either. He made a few posts on day one about what to repair, but they raised my suspicions on him more than anything, along with Cise. He then made a really suspicious move when he voted to repair the security grid, saying “I am repairing the security grid with cise”. Ark has claimed he has been busy with Homeworld, similar to Lomsor, but I feel like although Lomsor’s posts arent as detailed, they say far more about him and his thoughts than Ark’s do (I also have talked with Lomsor in the MedBay topic). I feel like Ark’s one semi-human-ey post came at the end of day two, but even then it just speculated about wild theories why Cosmos and Noble both made mistakes, and speculated about xamino as well.
Cise so far today has accused me (a known human to me!) and Sane (who I think is almost certainly a human). Cise has been provoking my suspicions since he posted in response to Topper, surprisingly he wasnt exactly on my radar at the beginning of the game as he usually is due to his analysis of the repair situation, however he has since thrown all that away. If you look back at the posts, the important contributions and ideas to the thread he has made is not very high, although as I said he had one decent post at the beginning of the game talking about structural integrity of the ship. His Popsicle offer at the end of day two was extremely suspicious, and he openly betrayed his group’s planned secrecy behind closed doors. He has tried to extract information from now-confirmed human Enginish at the expense of people I consider humans, and seemingly hasn’t put a lot of thought into the reasons he has given, or perhaps into his actions themselves.
Now for the two harder ones:
Xamino is tough, on the one hand, he has had a fundamental role in our random repair system (possibly compromised if he is a wolf?), but at first openly disagreed with Noble’s plan from the beginning, stating that pairs would be better still, despite discussions earlier in the thread about the very topic, with the conclusion being that pairs would be too easy for wolves to manipulate. The icing on the cake is the failed lynch compensate. If it was on purpose, why? For what gain? Possibly to take attention off of another wolf that might be accused? I am just speculating, it is really confusing, and of course could simply be an accident as claimed. Other than helping with the crypto-wizardry, he hasn’t really done much for the group, and has largely remained out of the conversation except to vote, voting for Krishna on day two and Skyentist on day one. The vote on Krishna I feel like was not really expected to be menacing, as he was the first to vote for Krishna, so if they are both wolves, it may simply be a way to cover up ties between them.
Pendrokar has certainly been more vocal than Xamino, thats for sure, but as others have pointed out his behavior this game is markedly different than his other games. On top of that, we all know he is a sneaky bastard, and that is the truth. Human or wolf, you know right now there is some shenanigans brewing in the security room. Pendrokar was one of the first to speak up about the possible uses of the systems, contributing greatly in that discussion on day one, which leads me to believe that he is of these two the more likely to be a human. On day one he voted for Krishna in order to pressure him to participate a bit, but was quiet for the rest of the day. On day two he started the band wagon on terran, a confirmed human now, after the sane first accused him. Pendrokar’s reasoning was that Terran had not contributed enough to the conversation, and I have to admit that even I (which is why i voted for him) was suspicious of Terran’s lack of contribution to the thread. He also brought up the point that the security grid would be down to two people if Terran was lynched, something a wolf probably would not do (they would rather leave it out of their post and hope no one noticed). I think, for now, that the wolves are trying to frame pendrokar, which is why Enginish was killed.
…Thoughts? Anyone?
