If the humans have an instant win condition, what did the wolves get? A bigger team? Powerful abilities? Or are the train stops the only balancing factor? 4 left doesn't have to mean that we hadn't killed any yet.
I had assumed that was your role, to get a report on night activity (and that we wouldn't get anything from it anyway due to the role block). If not that then an item from Redwater?
Nope. If there are 4 left and we kill a human first then wolves will probably win. This is why it is critical to share everything now and make the best judgement we can. Forcing a tie on day part one might even be the best option we have, just to extend the time we have to decide on who to kill. @martindevans would No lynch count as a vote?
A comment on Cybercritics death: Cybercritic did not pose any direct danger to the wolves as far as I can tell, but killing him does stop me from asking him a couple of questions. What exactly made him think Skyentist was the Alchemist? What made him conclude that the Wolfsbane potion was poison? Perhaps @Aquila can fill in these details.
If The Vigilante is still alive I would like to ask him to step forward. Even though Cosmos had the role for himself he would still have had to gain the cooperation of the real one, otherwise accusing Enginish and claiming to have been protected could easily backfire. Details on how he presented himself to you and and what you knew of the trap plan could be critical here. Unless you are Lucas, in which case you were dead. (Now we only have 1 night left there is little to worry about from revealing your identity, just protect yourself... or roll the dice, say you're going to protect yourself and protect someone else.)
On night one were you already cooperating with Cosmos? If so how did you come to trust each other so early in the game? Why exactly did you choose to confiscate Enginish's role at that point?
Is the wait over yet?
@mattk50, hi how are you feeling? Have you recovered from the surgery yet? Was this just a convenient excuse to gain sympathy and not be murdered?
@Lomsor, you're the only person who has shown interest in sharing info so far, I look forward to anything you have to say.
@NobleBrutus, I'm still not sure if you should get a pass for that Freudian slip!