Cise - The Grave Robber
A bit of an unknown for me, no apparent lies from him but has managed to keep to the "middle ground" throughout the game quite successfully. Voting for Cosmos, attempting to poison Enginish, adding his vote to the Kreydis Pile, but nothing that makes me sure he is human.
xamino - The Vigilante
I toyed with the idea that he might be a wolf, having killed the real Vigilante and used the role name to misdirect us, but the number of little details that have built up to support his claim is enough for me to stop pursuing that theory. I still question why he is so trusting of Cosmos / Aquila though. If they are wolves then their whole play has been to find ways of looking human. Not killing a person who trusts them means little, and if his role isn't as powerful as others believe then why kill someone who isn't a threat to them.
Topperfalkon - [Unknown]
Mystery is a mystery. Why he is logging in but not posting publicly is confusing, hopefully he hasn't suffered some sort of real life catastrophe. Too risky to kill, and if martin were to eliminate him from the game for inactivity at this point it might unfairly tip the balance in favor of one of the teams.
Lomsor - The Engineer
Probably a wolf. I'd like to see what his argument for lynching someone else would be after the train was stopped. He was first to vote for Kreydis but that doesn't prove anything, in fact it would explain Kreydis' outburst (being voted for by a fellow wolf). It was obvious that the double vote issue was going to be brought up, so why not be the first to do it? We also can not rely on his own description of how the role works. His argument that if he was a wolf he would have used it at the tunnel holds no water if its a daytime action.
Mattk50 - The Spy
Since the surgery he has been a little more active, and getting a gauge on him through our conversations in steam chat has been a little easier. I'm concerned he might be a wolf, his strategy for looking human last game involved making little innocent factual "mistakes" in his conversations while suggesting plausible suspicions. This appeared to be evident in my last chat with him, but its hardly conclusive. He is also one of the few players that could still be lying about their role, his reveal post (conveniently) didn't reveal anything we didn't already know... I'd like to know who he spied on last night.
Enginish - The Priest
I thought buying lynch protection would be quite unfair if all the wolves could do it, but given the number of roles that involved the ability to bypass the lynch and kill someone perhaps not. I'm not prepared to say that he is not a wolf, but if he is then he isn't working alone, and there are other more obvious suspects at this point in time. Perhaps @xamino can pick out the little details that have convinced him to vote for Enginish?
Aquila - The Conductor
Aquila being a wolf relies on the theory that the wolves have been making every effort possible to look like they are trustworthy humans. Except for the fact that she has answered maybe 1 in 5 of my questions, and none to my satisfaction. On top of that not wanting to split the vote is junk reasoning when you are only the third person to vote in the first half of the day. It's also possible The Engineer role being brought out in the open was a deliberate ploy to make a last ditch effort and argue that someone else must have copied the role.
Lomsor
