Alright well i was hoping i would get more replies but its a short day so i dont want to wait. Also roleplay to come from me soon! Didnt have much time for that yesterday and i just woke up.
In any case I think we can learn 2 things if we take enginish' post at face value:
He is NOT any sort of medic role. He may have another role that interacts with dead players but remains to be seen. I dont think this is the case though.
Speaking from a motive standpoint, the wolves would already know who everyone was regardless of alignment reveals. It seems less likely a wolf would ask this question since the information is redundant to them. I am leaning towards enginish being human, at least for now.
As for the replies, BrickWall seems to be committing a lot of mistakes, which i think are just a result of him being new. Hes indicated he has a role, has some reason to believe EVERYONE has a role and carelessly admitted so.
My take on this is that hes new, so i wont bash him so hard, but im curious why he thinks everyone has a role. The way i see it theres 2 possibilities:
He has a role and so just assumed that everyone must have gotten one as a result because hes new. (Likely)
He is a wolf, and has seen that all of the wolves have roles (possible, seen in past wolf games), and so assumes that if they all have roles, then all of the humans must also have roles.
I find Sane's suggestion to reveal roles also alarming. I know ive suggested something similar in the past, but i think experience shows us it was not a good idea at all. I do not agree with doing this. I also note that he probably has a role, from his post.
Lomsor, i do not think the post was a reaction getter. The world championships had such a mechanic in them, so I genuinely believe that he was asking out of legitimate curiosity. Granted, enginish is a crafty one, and you cant be too careful. Theres all kinds of levels of meta you can go with this, but day one im willing to take it at face value.
That being said i had an incredibly interesting conversation with King Cosmos last night about 8 hours from this post ago, and im absolutely convinced hes a wolf. Not ready to reveal everything yet, since most of what i have is a feeling.
That said, King_Cosmos has to die for his crimes!