Rocketry General Thread

I would love to work for a new space company.

One thing I had thought of and that is who in this new space era will be providing all the personal care and hygiene products to these private space flight and earth orbit space hotels and soon enough Moon base hotels. Including: Toilet rolls, toilet roll holders, wet wipes, soap dispensers, pens paper pads, small tablets etc. Showers, and toilet cleaning products etc, for earth orbit and Moon based. All the towels and other little day to day items what will need to be specially designed to be cheap, light and compact and mass produced to high quality standards.

Yeah, I wouldn’t mind getting in on the ground floor with a company set up to designs and produce all these much needed items and contracts to supply, clean and maintain etc. Its going to be big business sooner than we think once China lands humans back on the Moon. I expect that one single event will spark a new rush back to the Moon with and eye to creating staging posts for travel to Mars and the asteroid field.

Starting out with nearby companies I guess in South Wales, UK. I wonder if it could be a start up company, 3D print to a high standard some basic items any early space tourists would need to take on a short and long flights.

Interesting!

4 Likes

About Rockets!

FULL Elon Musk’s Speech at SpaceX 2017 Event

6 Likes

That was a truly inspiring presentation. Really hope they make it in 2022. :slight_smile:

And that intercontinental rocket… is just terrifying. With my fear of flight I would probably never set my foot in one :smiley: Unless there’s a flawless record of thousands of flights first.

2 Likes

Elon has always been very overconfident and overestimates delays…however I really want them to make the 2022 window as well and at this point it’s not impossible. The most impressive part to me is that they have ordered the tooling and plan to begin construction in 9 months. That’s what makes this whole thing real. On top of that, they’ve already created/tested the lightweight composite tanking structure needed to make the structural mass light enough to achieve their desired payloads. Along with 42 test fires of a subscale raptor, I spoke with a propulsion engineer last night during the presentation who said that these fires were with a subscale version at 2/3 the size of a flight engine. They’re almost there.

As far as the Earth to Earth stuff that’s farthest in the future in my opinion. It can’t and won’t happen for a long time mostly for political and geopolitical reasons, but also because their landing tech needs to be demonstrated and that can’t happen without repeated launches and landings from Mars missions.

The only way I think any Moon missions would happen is if it’s paid for by other actors which is a possibility and the reason why it was advertised. This is an expensive venture but if even 1 extra first stage and tanker craft is paid for by someone else, it can also be re-used towards launching Martian payloads which is their ultimate goal.

My personal favorite part was their method of fuel transfer. It’s a very elegant solution to what can easily balloons to a complicated problem.

4 Likes

Seems more fulfilling doesn’t it? If your work is for something that you care about.

It was great talk.
He was so nervous …like a human, not some actor or pop speaker…it was so relate-able.
I root for him. He is that underdog that made it.

2 Likes

I kept thinking about SLS during the presentation, and what success for SpaceX could do to the program.

1 Like

Are you kidding? That would be a disaster! No money to distribute in inefficient processes for overpaid companies, no expensively distributed facilities in as many circumscriptions as possible, no expensive programs artificially kept alive way past their usefulness…
It would get cancelled in a heartbeat.

He’s not nervous, he just doesn’t speak very fluently. There are plenty of videos of him speaking in which you can see and hear he’s perfectly relaxed and comfortable but his speech is the same.

He’s most hesitant when he’s trying to think of the words to use to express his thoughts.

Like many very intelligent people he has behaviours that are often associated with autism.

This topic is temporarily closed due to a large number of community flags.

3 Likes

Musk knows a big chunk of this is total nonsense but keeps churning out drek like it for publicity.

1 Like

Sorry of like his nonsense about reusable rockets and affordable electric cars?

1 Like

Other companies are working on both of those things (although the jury’s still out on whether those reusable rockets will save money long term when you end up spending so much more on the second stage).

I’m talking about the ludicrous claims (for several orders of magnitude reduction in price and increase in reliability than anything built in history) made of things like hyperloop, the mars colony, and now commercial aviation.

It’s pretty sad that the idea of a mars colony seems to be the least technically challenging of those three mentioned. That one isn’t intended to be commercially viable.

*I’m not saying Space X isn’t doing some cool stuff, they are; just that you should try not to get too wrapped up in corporate marketing campaigns of completely impossible futures.

Agreed, also don’t see how rockets can be affordable given rocket fuel prices. What’s more, doubt your average vacationer will be able to stand the kind of g’s involved in rocket transport. Unless of course passengers are tested and put through a centrifuge before flight. lol.

Look up the prices of Methane and Liquid Oxygen. They are really low. And rocket launch G-loads are surprisingly modest, nowhere near what jet fighter pilots experience during turns. Also, if you design a vehicle for tourism ( not Spacex priority, but for others ) you can set a G-load design limit and build for it. I would be much more worried about dozens or hundreds of people starting to puke at once in zero gravity. One starting would trigger more, and that would be quite a mess to contain and clean up. I expect everyone to get some medication before launch and a strict timetable of diet.

1 Like

Stated travel times are bogus without reasonably high g loads (unacceptable for general air passengers).
Stated travel times are bogus as they don’t include the trip to and from the rocket (by boat of all things).
The proximity to cities shown in their demonstration is bogus just on noise pollution grounds.
Rockets need far better weather than aircraft to fly, scheduling would be a nightmare.
Current rocket technology is orders of magnitude less safe than commercial aviation. SpaceX claim what, 93% reliability at the moment? Are they high?
Getting the rockets to their barges, recovery from a barges and general maintenance, connecting first and second stages… all far more expensive than aircraft.

There’s also the whole issue with turn-around times taking longer than the conventional flight you’re trying to beat. No way to possibly compete with what we already have. And everyone at SpaceX knows it. They’re just farting this out because it looks cool at face value.

Total non-starter, and that’s before you even start looking at the environmental disaster this would end up being.

1 Like

3 g’s is nothing to sneeze at especially for an average person; there would be so many restrictions and health requirements that it would be too prohibitive. What’s more, we are not talking about people taking jets and zig-zagging their way to another country so this comparison is moot. As for fuel it takes 384,071 gallons of liquid hydrogen in the external tank of the shuttle to reach low orbit, for a cost of $376,389.58. A flight from New York to London cost just over $24,000 dollars in fuel. Clearly rocket flight isn’t going to happen even in the distant future. A more realistic means of transporting people is a hypersonic jet; it would be more fuel efficient, less strenuous and safer. What Musk is doing is PR - it is not realistic means of mass transportation.

Compared to rockets, yes, but unfortunately probably not likely to happen as well.

We’ve already experimented with supersonic flights, but breaking the sound barrier (and staying above) takes way too much fuel to make it commercially viable. Military jets capable of supersonic flight, for example, rarely do so just because of the fuel costs, preferring to cruise at speeds comparable to most airliners.

2 Likes