The password reset feature is just the cause of the problem. The real problem is that I am unable log back into my original account. Any login attempt leads me to this account.
I've just tried again and am now unable to log in to both accounts. Attached the error I get when trying to get on the forums after entering my credentials into the login formula.
EDIT: Just to clarify, I'm posting this from my tablet which is still logged in. I won't change anything here until I can log in to any of the two accounts (xamino & xamino1).
EDIT2: Using the password reset function I get an email for both my old email address (from the old forum) and my new one (the current gmail address). However, both result in an error on login.